Subscribe to Updates

    Get the latest creative news from FooBar about art, design and business.

    What's Hot

    Impact of “infrastructure status” for the DC industry announced in the Union Budget 2022

    February 4, 2022

    Milestone Systems appoints new Chief Revenue Officer

    January 26, 2022

    IIM Udaipur Incubated tech startup FasterrWeb obtains funding

    January 25, 2022
    Facebook Twitter Instagram
    • Demos
    • Buy Now
    Facebook Twitter Instagram
    My BlogMy Blog
    Subscribe
    • Home
    • Features
      • Typography
      • Contact
      • View All On Demos
    • Typography
    • Buy Now
    My BlogMy Blog
    Home»Internet»Seeking to respin Instagram’s toxicity for teens, Facebook publishes annotated slide decks – TechCrunch
    Internet

    Seeking to respin Instagram’s toxicity for teens, Facebook publishes annotated slide decks – TechCrunch

    adminBy adminSeptember 30, 2021No Comments5 Mins Read
    Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
    Seeking to respin Instagram’s toxicity for teens, Facebook publishes annotated slide decks – TechCrunch
    Share
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email

    “The methodology is not fit to provide statistical estimates for the correlation between Instagram and mental health or to evaluate causal claims between social media and health/well-being,” Facebook writes in an introduction annotation on one of the slide decks. Aka “nothing to see here”.

    Later on, commenting on a slide entitled “mental health findings” (which is subtitled: “Deep dive into the Reach, Intensity, IG Impact, Expectation, Self Reported Usage and Support of mental health issues. Overall analysis and analysis split by age when relevant”), Facebook writes categorically that: “Nothing in this report is intended to reflect a clinical definition of mental health, a diagnosis of a mental health condition, or a grounding in academic and scientific literature.”

    While on a slide that contains the striking observation that “Most wished Instagram had given them better control over what they saw”, Facebook nitpicks that the colors used by its researchers to shade the cells of the table which presents the data might have created a misleading interpretation — “because the different color shading represents very small difference within each row”. 

    If the sight of Facebook publicly questioning the significance of internal work and quibbling with some of the decisions made by its own researchers seems unprepossessing, remember that the stakes of this particular crisis for the adtech giant are very high.

    The WSJ’s reporting has already derailed a planned launch of a “tweens” version of the photo-sharing app.

    While U.S. lawmakers are also demanding answers.

    More broadly, there are global moves to put child protection at the center of digital regulations — such as the U.K.’s forthcoming Online Safety Act (while its Age Appropriate Design Code is already in force).

    So there are — potentially — very serious ramifications for how Instagram will be able to operate in the future, certainly vis-à-vis children and teenagers, as regulations get drafted and passed.

    Facebook’s plan to launch a version of Instagram for under 13s emerged earlier this year, also via investigative reporting — with BuzzFeed obtaining an internal memo which described “youth work” as a priority for Instagram.

    But on Monday CEO Adam Mosseri said the company was “pausing” “Instagram kids” to take more time to listen to the countless child safety experts screaming at it to stop in the name of all that is good and right (we paraphrase).

    Whether the social media behemoth will voluntarily make that “pause” permanent looks doubtful — given how much effort it’s expending to try to reframe the significance of its own research.

    Though regulators may ultimately step in and impose child safety guardrails.

    “Contrary to how the objectives have been framed, this research was designed to understand user perceptions and not to provide measures of prevalence, statistical estimates for the correlation between Instagram and mental health or to evaluate causal claims between Instagram and health/well-being,” Facebook writes in another reframing notation, before going on to “clarify” that the 30% figure (relating to teenaged girls who felt its platform made their body image issues worse) “only” applied to the “subset of survey takers who first reported experiencing an issue in the past 30 days and not all users or all teen girls”. 

    So, basically, Facebook wants you to know that Instagram “only” makes mental health problems worse for fewer teenage girls than you might have thought.

    (In another annotation it goes on to claim that “fewer than 150 teen girls spread across… six countries answered questions about their experience of body image and Instagram”. As if to say, that’s totally okay then.)

    The tech giant’s wider spin with the annotated slides is an attempt to imply that its research work shows proactive “customer care” in action — as it claims the research is part of conscious efforts to explore problems experienced by Instagram users so that it can “develop products and experience for support”, as it puts it.

    Yeah we lol’d too.

    After all, this is the company that was previously caught running experiments on unwitting users to see if it could manipulate their emotions.

    In that case Facebook succeeded in nudging a bunch of users who it showed more negative news feeds to to post more negative things themselves. Oh and that was back in 2014! So you could say emotional manipulation is Facebook’s DNA… 

    But fast-forward to 2021 and Facebook wants you the public, and concerned parents everywhere, as well as U.S. and global lawmakers who are now sharpening their pens to apply controls to social media, not to worry about teenagers’ mental health — because it can figure out how best to push their buttons to make them feel better, or something.

    Turns out, when you’re in the ad sales business, everything your product does is an A/B test against some poor unwitting “user”…  

    Screengrab from one of Facebook’s annotated slide decks released in response to the WSJ’s reporting about teen Instagram users’ mental health issues (Screengrab: Natasha Lomas/TechCrunch.)

    Source Link

    annotated decks Facebook Instagrams publishes respin Seeking slide TechCrunch teens toxicity
    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
    admin
    • Website

    Related Posts

    Mphasis and CrossTower partner to develop a ‘Center of Excellence’ in Web 3.0 and Blockchain technologies

    January 21, 2022

    FTFT Subsidiary Launches Cryptocurrency Market Data Platform

    January 4, 2022

    Featuring Mr. Vladislav Sapozhnikov – Managing Partner Of Genesis Block At GITEX GLOBAL 2021

    November 13, 2021
    Add A Comment

    Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

    Editors Picks

    Onboard Cameras Allow Disabled Quadcopters to Fly

    January 5, 2021
    Top Reviews
    Advertisement
    Demo
    My Blog
    Facebook Twitter Instagram Pinterest Vimeo YouTube
    • Home
    • Buy Now
    © 2023 ThemeSphere. Designed by ThemeSphere.

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.